Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Adair Holdings, LLC v. Johnson

Supreme Court of Nebraska

January 3, 2020

Adair Holdings, LLC, appellant,
v.
Dennis G. Johnson et al., appellees.

         1. Standing: Jurisdiction: Parties. Standing is a jurisdictional component of a party's case because only a party who has standing may invoke the jurisdiction of a court.

         2. Jurisdiction: Appeal and Error. The question of jurisdiction is a question of law, upon which an appellate court reaches a conclusion independent of the trial court.

         3. Summary Judgment: Appeal and Error. An appellate court affirms a lower court's grant of summary judgment if the pleadings and admitted evidence show that there is no genuine issue as to any material facts or as to the ultimate inferences that may be drawn from the facts and that the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.

         4.__:__. In reviewing a summary judgment, an appellate court views the evidence in the light most favorable to the party against whom the judgment was granted, and gives that party the benefit of all reasonable inferences deducible from the evidence.

         5. Equity: Quiet Title. A quiet title action sounds in equity.

         6. Equity: Appeal and Error. On appeal from an equity action, an appellate court tries factual questions de novo on the record and, as to questions of both fact and law, is obligated to reach a conclusion independent of the conclusion reached by the trial court, provided that where credible evidence is in conflict on a material issue of fact, the appellate court considers and may give weight to the fact that the trial judge heard and observed the witnesses and accepted one version of the facts rather than another.

         7. Statutes: Appeal and Error. Statutory interpretation presents a question of law, for which an appellate court has an obligation to reach an independent conclusion irrespective of the decision made by the court below.

         [304 Neb. 721] 8. Title: Deeds: Tax Sale. Actions challenging title obtained via a tax deed are governed by statute.

         9. Title: Deeds: Tax Sale: Quiet Title. Because a void tax deed grants color of title in a potential future action, it will always be incumbent upon the original landowner to bring an action to quiet title in his or her name.

         10. Title: Deeds: Tax Sale: Words and Phrases. The word "paid" in Neb. Rev. Stat. § 77-1844 (Reissue 2009) includes tendering payment.

         11. Title: Deeds: Tax Sale: Jurisdiction: Notice. Neb. Rev. Stat. § 77-1843 (Reissue 2009) has a jurisdictional component that renders a tax deed void when the tax deed holder failed to comply with the statutory notice requirements prior to acquiring the deed.

         12. Title: Deeds: Tax Sale: Notice. A misstatement in the statutory notice of the expiration of the time of redemption renders the tax deed invalid.

         13. Quiet Title. The party seeking to quiet title must recover, if at all, on the strength of his own title and not on the weakness of his adversary's title.

         14. Equity. The relief ordinarily granted in equity is such as the nature of the case, the law, and the facts demand.

         15. Equity: Quiet Title. In quiet title actions, one who seeks equity must do equity.

         16. Appeal and Error. To be considered by an appellate court, an alleged error must be both specifically assigned and specifically argued in the brief of the party asserting the error.

          Appeal from the District Court for Franklin County: Terri S. Harder, Judge.

          Deana K. Walocha for appellant.

          Nicholas R. Norton, of Jacobsen, Orr, Lindstrom & Holbrook, P.C., L.L.O., for appellee Dennis G. Johnson.

          Heavican, C.J., Miller-Lerman, Cassel, Stacy, Funke, Papik, and Freudenberg, JJ.

          FREUDENBERG, J.

         NATURE OF CASE

         Adair Holdings, LLC, brought a quiet title action after obtaining a tax deed. Adair Holdings' predecessor in interest attempted to provide Dennis G. Johnson, the owner of record, [304 Neb. 722] with notice of the application for a tax deed via certified mail and then by publication. However, the notice contained incorrect information about the timeframe in which Johnson could redeem the property. On a motion for summary judgment, the trial court determined that the deed was void for incorrect notice and granted Johnson's counterclaim for quiet title. The court did not order Johnson to reimburse Adair Holdings for the delinquent taxes paid by Adair Holdings' predecessor in interest. Adair Holdings appeals.

         BACKGROUND

         Adair Asset Management, L.L.C. (Adair Management), and BMO Harris Bank purchased a tax sale certificate from Franklin County. This tax sale occurred in March 2014 for taxes that were unpaid from 2012. Adair Management then paid the delinquent taxes for 2013, 2014, and 2015 as well.

         After purchasing the tax certificate, Adair Management waited the 3-year statutory period set forth by Neb. Rev. Stat. § 77-1837 (Reissue 2009) and then sent notice in March 2017 by certified mail to Johnson's address of record. This notice indicated that Adair Management would be applying for a tax deed within 90 days if the property was not redeemed. The certified mail was marked as "Return to Sender, Unclaimed, Unable to Forward." After the attempt to provide notice by mail failed, notice was published in the Franklin County Chronicle newspaper on April 5, 12, and 19, 2017.

         The content of the notice included the statutory requirements of Neb. Rev. Stat. § 77-1831 (Reissue 2009). The notice also contained a phrase from a more recent version of § 77-1831, which phrase read:

If the property is owner occupied, the right of redemption shall expire at the close of business on the 45th day after the application for tax deed has been made. An additional redemption fee equal to twenty percent of all other amounts due must be paid if redemption is made after application for treasurer's deed has been made.

         [304 Neb. 723]This passage was a part of § 77-1831 (Cum. Supp. 2012); however, the statutory scheme contains a savings clause specifying that the 2009 law governs all tax sale certificates sold and issued between January 1, 2010, and December 31, 2014.[1] It does not appear from the record that Adair Management sent a copy of the published notice to Johnson's address of record.

         Adair Management and BMO Harris Bank applied for the tax deed on July 19, 2017. The application included an affidavit by counsel stating that Adair Management had complied with the statutory requirements and provided notice via unclaimed certified mail and by publication. The treasurer issued a tax deed on July 25, 2017, and recorded it on July 31. In August, Adair Management and BMO Harris Bank provided a quitclaim deed to Adair Holdings for land described as follows: "The Southeast Quarter (SE !4) of Section Five (5), Township Four (4) North, Range Fourteen (14), West of the 6th P.M. in Franklin County, Nebraska.''

         In October 2017, Adair Holdings commenced an action in equity to quiet title to the real estate in its name. Johnson filed an answer and a counterclaim requesting the court to quiet title in his name. Johnson argued that (1) the notice was statutorily defective for including a misstatement of law and (2) the notice was constitutionally defective according to Neb. Const, art. VIII, § 3, which requires that "occupants shall in all cases be served with personal notice before the time of redemption expires." In April 2018, Johnson served Adair Holdings with a set of requests for admissions and received no response.

         Johnson moved for summary judgment, and a hearing was held in September 2018. In an affidavit entered at the summary judgment hearing, Johnson averred that he first discovered the existence of the tax deed in early August 2017. Johnson claims that he then reviewed the published notice and relied on the notice in believing he had 45 days to redeem the property. The 45th day from the issuance of the tax deed was Saturday, [304 Neb. 724] September 2, 2017. Johnson attempted to tender payment to the ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.