MICHAEL GALLNER, AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF JUDY HOFFMAN, DECEASED, AND JORDAN GALLNER, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS GUARDIAN AND NEXT FRIEND OF MAKENZIE GALLNER, APPELLANTS,
C. GREGG LARSON, APPELLEE
[Copyrighted Material Omitted]
Appeal from the District Court for Douglas County: LEIGH ANN RETELSDORF, Judge.
Theodore R. Boecker, Jr., of Boecker Law, P.C., L.L.O., for appellants.
Joshua C. Dickinson and Shilee T. Mullin, of Spencer, Fane, Britt & Browne, L.L.P., for appellee.
HEAVICAN, C.J., WRIGHT, CONNOLLY, MILLER-LERMAN, and CASSEL, JJ. STEPHAN and MCCORMACK, JJ., not participating.
[291 Neb. 206] Heavican, C.J.
Michael Gallner (Gallner) filed a complaint against C. Gregg Larson alleging breach of fiduciary duty arising out of the attorney-client relationship, breach of fiduciary duty arising out of the duty of a trustee, and conversion. Gallner sought either money damages or the imposition of an oral or constructive trust as to proceeds paid out to Larson as beneficiary of various life insurance policies following the death of Judy Hoffman (Judy).
The district court dismissed Gallner's claims and entered judgment in Larson's favor. Gallner appeals. We affirm.
II. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Gallner and Judy were married in 1982 and divorced in 1994. There was one son as a result of their marriage, Jordan Gallner. Jordan is the father of Makenzie Gallner.
[291 Neb. 207] Judy was a resident of Omaha, Nebraska, and an attorney licensed to practice law. She died intestate on December 10, 2007. Gallner was named personal representative of her estate.
The present litigation involves Larson, who was a friend of Judy's. Judy and Larson met in the early 1990's when both represented different defendants in a federal criminal case. Over the years, Larson assisted Judy in various legal matters, including continuing legal matters relating to her divorce from Gallner. Larson, who resides in another state, would also periodically visit Omaha for personal and professional activities. On those visits, Larson would sometimes stay at Judy's home. Judy attended Larson's wedding and also attended Larson's wife's funeral. Judy introduced Larson to her parents. Jordan testified that Larson was a close friend of Judy's and that he, Jordan, telephoned Larson upon Judy's eventual death.
In November 1999, Judy engaged an attorney to draft a trust document. That document named Judy as trustee and Larson as successor trustee. Jordan was the beneficiary under the trust. In early 2000, Judy sent a copy of the trust document to Larson. Larson testified that he notified Judy he was not in a position to serve as trustee given his distance from Omaha. Larson provided no legal advice to Judy concerning the trust document. There is no indication that Judy ever executed this trust document.
At the same time Judy sent Larson this draft trust, she also sent two other documents. One, exhibit 158, was a handwritten note dated January 27, 2000, purportedly from Judy to Larson. This note read in full:
I looked for you on the news -- thought you might be handing out your business cards after that snowstorm interstate accident[.] Lots of broken bones & wrongful deaths -- That was sick, wasn't it?
[291 Neb. 208] Anyway, when you can, look this over. You're the executor or Trustee or whatever, if I die.
Also, I finally got approved on the life insurance. You're the straight-up beneficiary on that. It's yours.
Gallner objected to exhibit 158 on best evidence grounds because the exhibit was a photocopy of the original note, which was no longer available. That objection was overruled.
The other document was the beneficiary designation on a $100,000 American Family Life Insurance Company policy (American Family policy). Apparently, Jordan had originally been the primary beneficiary, but in late November 1999, Judy changed the primary beneficiary to Larson, who was listed as a " family friend." The contingent beneficiary had been, and remained, Judy's father.
In November 2000, Judy obtained employment as an instructor at a community college in Omaha. She met with the coordinator of benefits and compensation at the beginning of her employment. Judy's benefits included a " UnumProvident" life insurance policy (Unum policy) and a 403(b) retirement account. The record shows that the 403(b) account was split equally between a Fidelity Investments account and a TIAA-CREF account.
On the Unum policy, Judy designated Larson as her primary beneficiary and Jordan as her contingent beneficiary. On the Fidelity Investments account, Judy designated Larson as primary beneficiary and Jordan as contingent beneficiary. Judy did not make any mention of a trust or trustee on either of Larson's designations. Larson is identified as " friend/atty" where the relationship is requested.
However, on the TIAA-CREF account, Judy designated Jordan as primary beneficiary and Larson as contingent beneficiary. Jordan was also designated as primary beneficiary for distribution of final pay and accumulated leave pay from the college, with Larson listed as contingent beneficiary.
In the fall of 2007, Judy engaged attorney Larry Forman to draft a last will and testament. The draft will and cover letter [291 Neb. 209] were sent to Judy on October 11. The will designated the distribution of Judy's tangible personal property and " insurance policies and claims under such policies on such property" to Jordan, with the remainder of her estate to Jordan and Makenzie. The trustee and personal representative under this will was to be Larson. On its face, the will does not indicate any intention with regard to any life insurance policies, nor does it contemplate ...